MAYDAY HANDCRAFTED ICE CREAM, St. Augustine - 1835 US Highway 1 S - Menu, Prices & Restaurant Reviews - Tripadvisor Learn more Mayday Ice Cream - Downtown St. Augustine - Learn more Forgive the bad picture, but I love the artwork depicting the San Marco lions as grumpy kitty cats. : r/jacksonville Learn more Local Takeout Highlight: Mayday Ice Cream | Jacksonville Magazine Learn more Mayday Ice Cream (Hendricks Avenue) Menu, Prices, Delivery - DoorDash Learn more Mayday Ice Cream releases new flavor on May 21 for Third Birthday! | Totally St. Augustine Learn more The Scoop on the Latest Ice Cream Cool Spots in Jax Learn more St. Augustine ice cream shop opens new location in San Marco | Learn more