How to Choose the Perfect Ice Cream Maker

If you’ve ever craved old-fashioned homemade ice cream, then you know the joy of indulging in a creamy, delightful treat. In this guide, we’ll explore the world of old-fashioned ice cream makers and provide you with helpful tips for selecting the best machine to satisfy your frozen dessert cravings. From electric to hand crank models, we’ve got you covered.

The Timeless Charm of Homemade Ice Cream

As an ice cream enthusiast, I’ve always cherished the memories of making ice cream with my family. Both my grandpa and my parents were my mentors in the art of creating this frozen delight. I can still feel the burn in my arm as I turned the crank on my grandpa’s old ice cream maker, and I can taste the nostalgia in every scoop of my mom’s homemade banana ice cream.

On my blog, I’ve shared countless recipes and stories about ice cream, but it’s high time I provide you with a comprehensive guide to help you choose your own ice cream maker. Let’s dive in!

How Does It Work?

Ice cream has a rich history, and it’s fascinating to think that the hand cranked ice cream maker was invented just 179 years ago by American Nancy Johnson. Today, these machines still operate on the same principles.

Whether you’re using a hand crank or an electric motor, an old-fashioned ice cream maker comprises a metal canister nestled in a mixture of ice and rock salt. The rock salt accelerates the freezing process, resulting in a smooth and velvety texture that’s simply irresistible.

The cold edges of the canister freeze the ice cream, while the churn paddle continuously scrapes the frozen treat from the edges and replaces it with the warmer mixture from the center. This constant churning gradually freezes all the contents, transforming them into the luscious ice cream we all adore.

Making Ice Cream with an Old-Fashioned Maker

Before you embark on your ice cream-making journey, make sure your ice cream freezer is clean and ready for action. While not essential, I highly recommend using an electric mixer to mix your ice cream ingredients. A stand-up mixer or even a small hand mixer will do the trick. You might even find success using a blender, just like my dad did!

Now, let’s get to the timing. Freezing ice cream in an old-fashioned maker can take anywhere between 30 to 45 minutes. However, it’s always best to keep an eye on the consistency and trust your instincts.

Once the motor stops, indicating that your ice cream is ready, it’s time to unplug your machine. Remove any excess ice or salt from the lid, take out the churn paddle (and decide who gets to lick it!), and scoop your ice cream into bowls for serving. If you’ve opted for a hand crank ice cream maker, get ready for a good arm workout!

Things to Consider Before Buying an Ice Cream Maker

Investing in an ice cream maker requires thoughtful consideration. To help you make an informed decision, here are a few key factors to keep in mind:

• Choose between a hand crank or an electric motor. Hand crank makers are not necessarily cheaper, and they demand more time and attention compared to their electric counterparts.
• Consider the size of the batch you want to make and how often you plan to indulge in homemade ice cream. Ice cream makers come in various capacities, ranging from personal-sized (1 quart) to large (2-4+ quarts). For our family, a 4-quart ice cream maker suits our needs perfectly, offering leftovers for future cravings or gatherings.
• Noise levels can vary among different ice cream makers. If you’re sensitive to noise, make sure to select a quieter option.

Choose Your Dream Ice Cream Maker

Now that you’ve considered the important factors, it’s time to find the ice cream maker of your dreams. Here are some of my favorite ice cream makers on the market:

• Richmond Cedar Works Ice Cream Maker Model 71: This 4-quart ice cream and frozen yogurt freezer is the exact model we use at home. While it may require some hunting to find this specific vintage machine, there are plenty available on eBay. Keep an eye out at yard sales, flea markets, antique stores, and auctions for other hidden gems.
• Immergood Stainless Steel Hand Crank Ice Cream Maker: This high-quality, hand crank ice cream maker boasts a triple-layer construction for efficient insulation. With its extra-large 6-quart capacity, it’s perfect for those craving a truly old-fashioned experience.
• Elite Gourmet Old Fashioned Wood Bucket Electric Maker Machine: Combining the convenience of an electric motor with the charm of a hand crank, this ice cream maker offers the best of both worlds. Its easy-cleaning, dishwasher-safe 4-quart aluminum canister and wooden freezer are truly a sight to behold.
• Nostalgia Electric Bucket Maker: For those seeking a hassle-free option, this electric ice cream maker will satisfy your cravings. With its easy-to-clean 4-quart plastic bucket and attractive wooden freezer, it’s a great addition to any kitchen.
• Elite Gourmet Electric Motorized Ice Cream Maker: This budget-friendly electric ice cream maker features a galvanized bucket and a 4-quart capacity, making it ideal for most families. It may not be the most glamorous option, but it gets the job done.
• Hamilton Beach Automatic Ice Cream Maker: Offering affordability without compromising on capacity, this electric ice cream maker has a sizable 4-quart canister. Its plastic construction and easy-lock lid make cleanup a breeze.

Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Maker Recipes

Now that you have all the tools and knowledge to create your homemade ice cream, it’s time to explore some delicious recipes. Get ready to embark on a journey of flavors that will transport you to ice cream heaven!

Watch the Whole Process from Start to Finish

CRAVING MORE DELICIOUS RECIPES? Subscribe to my newsletter and follow along on Pinterest, Facebook, YouTube, and Instagram for all the latest updates!