Healthy ice cream – or good-for-you ice cream..? – Bayn Solutions


Here are the best information about Is ice cream unhealthy voted by readers and compiled and edited by our team, let’s find out

During the fair held by the asso­ci­a­tion for food and bev­er­age pro­duc­ers in Sweden, Bayn served ice cream with­out added sug­ar. It was sup­plied by Engelholms Glass and it con­tains our sweet­ened fibres. We received a huge­ly pos­i­tive response! “That is so tasty! It’s amaz­ing.. I’ll get my col­leagues – they just have to try this!”

Affirmation is great.

Among the praise there were also ques­tions: “Hm, what are we sup­posed to expe­ri­ence when eat­ing this ice cream? Are we to per­ceive it as healthy?”

Not a simple black-and-white issue

The ques­tions stuck, as good ques­tions do. Really good ques­tions chal­lenge and probe, and demand nuanced answers. And so they should when we deal with dis­cus­sions on food and bev­er­age these days. And they got me thinking.

I kept com­ing back to the ques­tion if the ice cream was healthy, or not. Since it con­tained clear traces of pathos, ethos and logos – val­ue, cred­i­bil­i­ty and logic.

Today we are usu­al­ly swayed by sim­pler mes­sages than pathos, ethos and logos. We are more like­ly to be fed antithe­ses. A rhetoric where good is set against bad. Right against wrong. Healthy against unhealthy.

A common enemy

But if the ques­tion is com­pli­cat­ed, it requires a com­pli­cat­ed answer. Two good exam­ples is when food and bev­er­age com­pa­nies put antithe­sis against the­sis, is Oatly’s and Kronfågel’s cam­paigns. Oatly makes milk like prod­ucts from oat, Kronfågel sells chick­en prod­ucts. Both oat grow­ers and chick­en farm­ers have spo­ken out against these cam­paigns where these suc­cess­ful busi­ness­es were try­ing to make con­sumers believe that oat is bet­ter than milk, and chick­en is bet­ter than beef.

When human­i­ty is under a com­mon threat choic­es should be easy. We are pre­sent­ed with a com­mon ene­my here: cows. They look so kind, but now seem almost criminal…

Messages with clear argu­ments, with pros and cons, are there to sim­pli­fy my dai­ly choic­es, to awak­en emo­tion and to con­vince. Now isn’t that nice! My life is already full of dif­fi­cult choic­es. Choices that con­cern not only the recy­cling under my sink, but the con­stant flow of infor­ma­tion, every­day deci­sions, and in the meet­ing of new people.

But in the con­text of these cam­paigns the mes­sages are sim­pli­fied, and this is why the crit­i­cism is so severe.

What constitutes “healthy”, really?

When the ques­tion was put to us at the fair – if you’re meant to think that the ice cream is healthy as it con­tains fibres, the eas­i­est solu­tion would have been to give a yes or no answer.

However, it’s rather dif­fi­cult to actu­al­ly define “healthy”, and how we are to per­ceive sug­ar reduced ice cream. It is after all a prod­uct that we need to place in the cat­e­go­ry of sweets. Just like that piece of choco­late, that cook­ie and the ener­gy bar we eat in between our – hope­ful­ly – nutri­tious and healthy meals.

When I was think­ing about what can be con­sid­ered healthy, I came across a study on two dia­met­ri­cal­ly opposed diets. The com­mon aim of both of them were to pre­vent, or lose, unhealthy weight and its con­se­quences. We all know that healthy eat­ing habits can con­tribute to a reduced risk of over­weight, car­dio­vas­cu­lar dis­eases, type 2 dia­betes and cancer.

The result from the study is rather aston­ish­ing – and lib­er­at­ing in these times of black and white answers.

It doesn’t matter

The study, per­formed by sci­en­tists at Stanford University in the US, let their sub­jects’ genet­ic pre­dis­po­si­tions deter­mine whether they would be put on a low carb diet, where high fat foods would be allowed, or on a low fat diet, where carbs were allowed. In oth­er words, two com­plete­ly dif­fer­ent diets. As con­cerned what else they would eat, the more than 600 par­tic­i­pants were encour­aged to just eat gen­er­al­ly healthy foods.

After a year it was time to eval­u­ate the result. It turned out it does­n’t mat­ter what type of diet we choose.

We can rid our­selves of unhealthy fac­tors no mat­ter the diet. We don’t have to put one diet against anoth­er. No diet is thus bet­ter than anoth­er. Both result in the desired benefit.

What sci­en­tists did rec­om­mend is some­thing we have heard for a long time now: It is bet­ter for your health to cut back on fast carbs like wheat flour and sug­ar. No mat­ter your diet.

It could be an argu­ment for sug­ar reduced ice cream being healthy, or at least health­i­er than ice cream with sug­ar. But that would be to sim­ple an answer.

Eat the ice cream because it tastes good

Ice cream with sweet­ened fibres does not con­tain any added sug­ar. That’s a fact. But I would like to qual­i­fy this state­ment and say that the sweet­ened fibres are ben­e­fi­cial to con­sumers who want to reduce their sug­ar intake yet still be able to eat ice cream. They may do it for health rea­sons. Or it may be a choice of diet or lifestyle where fast calo­ries have no part.

But ice cream is after all a prod­uct that we eat because we enjoy it. It’s a treat, not a meal. If you want to be healthy you’re more like­ly to choose some­thing com­plete­ly dif­fer­ent to eat. Ice cream – sug­ar reduced or not – is per­haps not some­thing we should eat for break­fast. But we can still enjoy it, per­haps a lit­tle lat­er in the day.

And if it tastes good, does it mat­ter if the ice cream con­tains sweet­ened fibres or sug­ar? It’s a sun­ny day, and the ice cream is sim­ply delicious.

0 ( 0 votes )

Ice Cream
Getting the best ice cream near me is easy! Find the nearest ice cream shop with our store locator. View hours, contact information, maps and driving directions