The Ultimate Guide to the Best Ice Cream in New York City

Best ice cream New York City

Post Overview: Roundup of the best ice cream in New York City

Looking for the ultimate ice cream experience in the vibrant foodie capital of America? Look no further! In this guide, I’ll take you on a delicious journey through the best ice cream shops in the Big Apple. From unique flavors to artisanal creations, New York City has it all. So, let’s dive in and satisfy your sweet tooth!

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream

Best Ice Cream New York City

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream first gained popularity from their humble food truck beginnings. Today, they have 19 ice cream shops in New York City alone, a testament to their success and dedication to quality. What sets them apart is their commitment to creativity, offering monthly flavors like brown sugar cookie dough, Sicilian pistachio, and earl gray tea. What’s even better? They use only natural ingredients and even have a range of delicious vegan options. Van Leeuwen is undoubtedly a local gem for those seeking unique ice cream in NYC.

Address: 19 ice cream shops in New York City

Emack & Bolio’s

Best Ice Cream in New York City

Let’s take a nostalgic trip back to the 1970s when Emack & Bolio’s was born. This ice cream shop has a fascinating backstory, starting as a clever solution to the limitations of Massachusetts blue laws. Today, Emack & Bolio’s serves some of the best ice cream in New York City, with flavors like Deep Purple Chip (a tribute to a famous rock band) and a variety of small-batch vegan options. Indulge in their playful ice cream combinations, like cones dipped in Reese’s Puffs, Rice Krispy Treats, and Fruity Pebbles. Emack & Bolio’s is an absolute treat for your taste buds.

See also  How to Easily Transport Ice Cream Cone Cupcakes

Address: 4 ice cream shops in New York City

Sundaes and Cones

Sundae and Cones, located just 10 minutes from Union Square Park, is a hidden gem among the best ice cream shops in New York City. This East Village treasure offers a delightful twist with its unique Asian-inspired flavors like taro and Thai iced tea. Enjoy the friendly and helpful staff who are always ready to suggest the perfect scoop. Don’t miss out on the cookie and brownie toppings for an extra touch of sweetness. Grab a cone, head to the park, and savor your delicious ice cream while enjoying some people watching.

Address: 95 E 10th St, New York, NY 10003

New York City Best Ice Cream

Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream

Step into Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream for a nostalgic American diner experience with a modern twist. This New York City ice cream shop exudes a classic vibe with its clean tiles and friendly staff. Apart from their classic ice cream flavors, Morgenstern’s is known for their innovative creations. Try their famous ice cream burger, featuring Neapolitan ice cream flavors sandwiched between hamburger buns and served with a side of fries. Morgenstern’s pays tribute to the classics while keeping up with ever-changing trends. It’s a must-visit among the best ice cream shops in NYC.

Address: 88 W Houston St, New York, NY 10012

Best ice cream New York City

OddFellows Ice Cream Co.

Best Ice Cream in New York City

OddFellows Ice Cream Co. is a true innovator in the world of frozen desserts. With over 500 flavors released since their inception, they are always pushing the boundaries of flavor creativity. This New York City ice cream shop guarantees something new and exciting every time you visit. From classic favorites to unexpected combinations, OddFellows has it all. With their dedication to quality and constant innovation, it’s no wonder that they have earned a spot among the best ice cream shops in NYC.

See also  How to Enjoy Sorbet Without an Ice Cream Maker

Address: 4 ice cream shops in Brooklyn

Ample Hills Creamery

Best New York City Ice Cream

Ample Hills Creamery is a crowd favorite when it comes to the best ice cream in New York City. With several locations throughout the Big Apple, each visit guarantees a scoop of pure delight. What sets Ample Hills apart is their commitment to freshness and quality. They have the largest ice cream production facility in NYC, ensuring that each scoop is as fresh as can be. Not to mention, they bake all their toppings in-house, adding an extra touch of deliciousness. Indulge in their wide variety of flavors and experience the joy that comes with each creamy bite.

Address: 9 ice cream shops in New York City

Mikey Likes It

Mikey Likes It

Mikey Likes It is a true hidden gem among the best ice cream shops in New York City. Located in the vibrant East Village, this small business creates artisan ice cream from natural and organic ingredients. With a focus on quality and flavor, Mikey Likes It offers a range of unique and delicious creations. Be sure to try their famous ice cream sandwiches called Mac Daddies, where any scoop of your choice is sandwiched between tasty waffles. Don’t just take my word for it – Mikey Likes It has garnered attention from Forbes, ABC News, and the Food Network.

Address: 199 Avenue A, New York, NY 10009

La Newyorkina

NYC Ice Cream

La Newyorkina brings the authentic flavors of Mexico to the streets of New York City. As someone who grew up on Mexican sweets, I can attest to the nostalgic taste that La Newyorkina delivers. While they only have one brick-and-mortar location, their offerings are worth seeking out. Indulge in their mouthwatering mangoneadas, babka ice cream sandwiches, and classic paletas. You’ll be transported back to the streets of Mexico with every bite. For a smaller selection, check out their kiosk at the Highline. La Newyorkina is a true taste of Mexico in the heart of NYC.

See also  The Best Ice Cream in Myrtle Beach: Unlocking the Sweet Secrets

Address: 61 Commerce St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

Sugar Hill Creamery

Sugar Hill Creamery

Sugar Hill Creamery is a family-owned and operated ice cream shop that has quickly become a favorite among locals. Located in Harlem, this creamery offers handmade ice cream that showcases both Caribbean and Midwestern influences. With their playful and cheeky flavor names, Sugar Hill Creamery delivers not only delicious treats but also a sense of community. Each scoop is made with love and the finest ingredients. Visit one of their three locations and indulge in the rich and creamy goodness that sets Sugar Hill Creamery apart.

Address: 3 in New York City

Caffè Panna

NYC best ice cream Caffe Panna

For an indulgent and luxurious ice cream experience, Caffè Panna is the place to be. Located in Gramercy Park, this Italian-inspired ice cream shop takes pride in their in-house creations. With a wide range of flavors, including weekly rotating specials, Caffè Panna guarantees a taste sensation with every visit. Whether you’re a fan of traditional flavors or crave something more adventurous, this NYC ice cream shop has you covered. Don’t miss out on their famous affogato, an exquisite blend of ice cream and espresso. Follow their Instagram to discover the weekly flavors and get ready for a truly decadent treat.

Address: 77 Irving Pl, New York, NY 10003

NYC best ice cream Caffe Panna

Milk Bar

NYC best ice cream

Milk Bar is a legendary ice cream destination in New York City. Known for their cereal-milk soft serve and the iconic Milk Bar Pie (affectionately nicknamed “crack cake”), this place has become a viral sensation. Indulge in their famous Birthday Cake, a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With eight locations throughout NYC, you’re never far from a delicious treat. Milk Bar offers a range of irresistible flavors that caters to everyone’s taste buds. Give in to your cravings and experience the magic of Milk Bar.

See also  Easy Recipe for Creamy Ice Cream without a Machine

Address: 8 locations in New York City

Sweet Churros

Sweet Churros

Sweet Churros is not your traditional ice cream shop, but it’s an experience you won’t want to miss. Watch as your churros are made to order right in front of your eyes. The warm, crispy churros paired with cold, sweet ice cream create a heavenly combination. It’s the perfect dessert for any ice cream lover. Treat yourself to this unique and delightful experience at Sweet Churros.

Address: 11 W 32nd St, New York, NY 10001

L’Arte Del Gelato

L'arte del Gelato cart outside the Chelsea Market, best ice cream NYC

If you’re looking for authentic Sicilian gelato, L’Arte Del Gelato is the place to be. Since 2005, this gelato shop has been serving some of the best ice cream in New York City. With their vibrant stands and wide range of flavors, L’Arte Del Gelato offers a taste of Italy right in the heart of NYC. Each scoop is made with fresh and natural ingredients, creating a truly authentic gelato experience. Visit one of their four locations and let your taste buds take a trip to Italy.

Address: 4 ice cream shops in New York City

Ice Cream NYC

16 Handles

16 Handles

16 Handles is a self-serve ice cream franchise that gives you complete control over your dessert experience. With a variety of flavors and toppings to choose from, you can create your own personalized ice cream masterpiece. Fill up your cup with as much or as little as you desire, and pay by weight. Whether you prefer a classic flavor or want to experiment with unique combinations, 16 Handles offers endless possibilities. It’s the perfect spot for the creative ice cream lover in you.

See also  Enjoy Delicious and Healthy "Ice Cream" with Yonanas Fruit To Ice Cream Maker

Address: 11 ice cream shops in New York City

Venchi 1878

Venchi Best Ice Cream NYC

Venchi 1878 is a delightful surprise that you won’t want to miss. With multiple locations throughout New York City, their ice cream is an absolute gem. Indulge in their delicious raspberry and strawberry sorbet or the delightful tiramisu gelato. Each scoop is incredibly fresh and creamy, delivering a taste experience like no other. Venchi 1878 has quickly earned its spot among the best ice cream shops in NYC, offering a true treat for ice cream enthusiasts.

Address: 8 ice cream shops in New York City

New York City Best Ice Cream (Post Summary)

In summary, here’s a quick rundown of the best ice cream shops in New York City:

  1. Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
  2. Emack & Bolio’s
  3. Sundaes and Cones
  4. Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream
  5. OddFellows Ice Cream Co.
  6. Ample Hills Creamery
  7. Mikey Likes It
  8. La Newyorkina
  9. Sugar Hill Creamery
  10. Caffè Panna
  11. Milk Bar
  12. Sweet Churros
  13. L’Arte Del Gelato
  14. 16 Handles
  15. Venchi 1878

Map of the Best Ice Cream in NYC

Cheers to a delightful ice cream adventure in the Big Apple!

Note: This article is focused on “Ice Cream,” and if you’re looking for more information, visit Ice Cream.

Getting the best ice cream near me is easy! Find the nearest ice cream shop with our store locator. View hours, contact information, maps and driving directions

Related Posts

Explore the Best Ice Cream in Bar Harbor

Explore the Best Ice Cream in Bar Harbor

My family has a tradition whenever we go on vacation – we have to get ice cream every night. Growing up, we spent a lot of time…

Homemade Ice Cream with Ice Cream Maker: A Delightful Treat

Homemade Ice Cream with Ice Cream Maker: A Delightful Treat

I scream, you scream, we all scream for HOMEMADE ice cream! This delightful treat is not only rich, creamy, and packed with vanilla flavor but is also…

McDonald’s Ice Cream: Affordable and Delicious Treats

Who hasn’t enjoyed McDonald’s Ice Cream yet? Cheap and tasty, their ice cream selection is unbeatable, whether you’re opting for a McFlurry, Sundae, or anything else! One…

Breyers Non-Dairy Ice Cream: Indulgence at Its Best

Breyers Non-Dairy Ice Cream: Indulgence at Its Best

I’ve always appreciated companies that don’t mess around, and Breyers is one of them. When it comes to their Non-Dairy Ice Cream, they don’t bother with small…

Indulge in a Delicious Peanut Butter Milkshake Without Ice Cream

Are you ready to revolutionize your milkshake game? Say goodbye to store-bought ice cream filled with unhealthy additives and sugars. Introducing a game-changer in the world of…

Goody’s Chocolates & Ice Cream: A Sweet Adventure in Central Oregon

The anticipation grew as we made our way down the hallway, wondering what delightful treats Maddy would unveil from her cart. In the heart of Bend, there…