During the warm summer months, nothing beats indulging in a delicious frozen treat. But where can you find the very best ice cream in Ohio? We asked PBS fans to share their favorite spots, and the results are in! From Cincinnati to Cleveland and everywhere in between, here are the top recommendations for satisfying your sweet tooth in the Buckeye State.
Ice Cream Gems Across Ohio
Cincinnati: Aglamesis Brothers
Starting off our list is Aglamesis Brothers in Cincinnati. Situated at 3046 Madison Rd, this charming ice cream parlor is a local favorite. With a heritage that dates back to 1908, Aglamesis Brothers has perfected the art of crafting delectable frozen treats. From classic flavors to unique creations, they offer something for everyone. Be sure to visit their website for more details.
Catawba Island: Andy’s Party Mart
Next up, we have Andy’s Party Mart in Catawba Island. Located at 2048 E Sand Rd, this hidden gem is a must-visit for ice cream enthusiasts. Offering a wide variety of flavors and toppings, Andy’s Party Mart is a delightful spot to beat the summer heat. Whether you’re in the mood for a cone, sundae, or milkshake, they have you covered. Check out their website for more information.
Cleveland: Apple Cart
In the heart of Cleveland, you’ll find Apple Cart at 4313 Superior Ave. This family-owned ice cream parlor has been serving up frozen delights since 1973. With a commitment to quality and flavor, Apple Cart is a beloved destination for locals and tourists alike. Treat yourself to their mouthwatering creations, and don’t forget to explore their website for more details.
Sylvania: Charlie’s Ice Cream and Edibles
If you find yourself in Sylvania, be sure to visit Charlie’s Ice Cream and Edibles on W Sylvania Ave. This charming establishment has been delighting customers with their homemade ice cream since 1995. Using only the finest ingredients, Charlie’s offers a wide range of flavors that are sure to satisfy any craving. Check out their website for more information.
A Statewide Ice Cream Adventure
As you venture through Ohio, make sure to stop by these other incredible ice cream destinations:
- Canal Fulton: Cherry Street Creamery
- Eastlake: Cooper’s Ice Cream Shop
- Yellow Springs: Corner Cone
- Richfield: Country Maid Ice Cream
- Findlay: Dietsch Brothers
- Cincinnati: Dojo Gelato
- Lebanon: Double Dip
- Parma Heights: East Coast Custard
- Cincinnati: Graeters
- Lancaster: Gypsy Joes
- Youngstown: Handel’s
- Wooster: Hartzler Family Dairy
- Canton: Heggy’s Nut Shop
- Cleveland: Honey Hut
- Englewood: JD Custards
- Columbus: Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream
- Marion: JerZee
- Columbus: Johnson’s Real Ice Cream
- Girard: Katie’s Korner
- St. Clairsville: Kirke’s Homemade Ice Cream
- Westerville: Knight’s Ice Cream
- Fairport Harbor: Kurlee Kone
- Shakeville: Lombardi’s
- Loveland: Loveland Sweet’s
- North Olmstead: Malley’s Chocolate Shoppes
- Columbus: Mardi Gras
- Jackson: Michael’s Ice Cream
- Cleveland: Mitchell’s Ice Cream
- Hartville: New Baltimore Ice Cream
- Delaware: Ollie’s Fine Ice Cream
- Akron: Pav’s Creamery
- Lima: Pete’s Ice Cream
- Cincinnati: Putz’s Creamy Whip
- Beavercreek: Ritter’s Frozen Custard
- Beaver Creek: Spinoza’s Gourmet Pizza & Salads
- Kent: Stoddard’s
- Stow: Stow Cone
- Akron: Strickland’s Frozen Custard
- Cleveland: Sweet Moses
- Cleveland Heights: Sweetie Fry
- Van Wert: Sycamore of Van Wert
- Canton: Taggarts Ice Cream Parlor & Restaurant
- Delphos: The Creamery
- Sandusky: Toft Dairy
- Zanesville: Tom’s
- Cincinnati: United Dairy Farmers
- Utica: Velvet Ice Cream
- Blue Ash: Whit’s Frozen Custard
- Cincinnati: Wiggy Dip
- Yellow Springs: Young’s Dairy
- Hinckley: Z’s Cream and Bean
Discovering the Best Ice Cream in Ohio
Ohio is home to an impressive array of ice cream destinations. Whether you prefer classic flavors or innovative creations, you’ll find something to satisfy your cravings. As you embark on your ice cream journey through Ohio, make sure to visit the establishments mentioned.
Remember, for more information on the best ice cream in Ohio, visit the Ice Cream directory. Happy ice cream hunting!
