With a wide selection of over 100 flavors of fro-yo, ice cream, sorbet, gelato, and vegan soft serve, 16 Handles takes pride in offering the most delicious desserts near you. Everyone has their favorite flavors, from the classic choices like vanilla to the more unique ones like spicy Chocolate Chipotle. In this article, we will explore the 16 most popular 16 Handles flavors that are still available today!
Tahitian Vanilla Bean
Tahitian Vanilla Bean is our most popular flavor for good reason. These vanilla beans are renowned for their rich floral notes, as they are allowed to fully mature before harvesting. If you’re a fan of that nostalgic vanilla swirl, you can’t go wrong with Tahitian Vanilla Bean. This gluten-free and all-natural flavor was one of our very first 16 Handles Artisan recipes.
16 Handles Recommended Toppings: Ghirardelli™ caramel sauce, white chocolate chips, Mini M&M’s, almonds, Cap’n Crunch
Chocolicious
For all the chocolate lovers out there, Chocolicious is a dream come true. This fro-yo flavor is made with only six simple ingredients and is low fat, all-natural, and gluten-free. Indulge in the decadent goodness of Chocolicious, the ultimate chocolate lover’s delight!
16 Handles Recommended Toppings: Nutella, caramel turtles, double chocolate cookie dough, brownie bites, chocolate chips
Salted Caramel
Our Salted Caramel flavor is a must-try. It’s completely fat-free and gluten-free, making it a guilt-free indulgence. Originally a limited-time-only flavor, Salted Caramel became a permanent fixture on our menu due to popular demand. Treat yourself and top it off with your favorite toppings!
16 Handles Recommended Toppings: Cookie dough bites, Ghirardelli™ caramel sauce, chocolate chips, graham cracker crumbs
Eurotart
Eurotart is our classic tart frozen yogurt that has been with us since the day we opened in 2008. It’s a fat-free and gluten-free option that can be enjoyed on its own or with fruity toppings. Start your day with a refreshing Eurotart breakfast or enjoy it as a light lunch option!
16 Handles Recommended Toppings: Fresh berries, mochi, granola, coconut flakes, honey, raspberry sauce
Birthday Cake
Why choose between cake and ice cream when you can have both? Our Birthday Cake flavor combines the richness of cake batter with the creaminess of soft serve. It’s a low-fat fro-yo flavor that allows you to celebrate any day!
16 Handles Recommended Toppings: Rainbow sprinkles, cheesecake bites, black & white cookies, chocolate chips
Cookies & Cream
Cookies & Cream is a staple in our fro-yo lineup. This deliciously sweet and decadent soft serve pairs well with almost every other flavor and topping. It’s perfect for kids or anyone with a sweet tooth. Get ready for a crunchy and creamy delight with crushed OREO™ mixed in!
16 Handles Recommended Toppings: Black & white cookies, crushed OREO™, chocolate rocks, Mini M&M’s, chocolate cookie crunch, Ghirardelli™ white chocolate sauce
So Fresh Mango Sorbetto
Looking for something refreshing? Our So Fresh Mango Sorbetto is our most popular sorbet flavor and happens to be our founder’s favorite. It is made with Alphonso mangoes from India, known for their exceptional flavor. This vegan, dairy-free, fat-free, and gluten-free sorbet is made with only four simple, natural ingredients.
16 Handles Recommended Toppings: Fresh fruit, coconut flakes, strawberry bursting bubbles, mango bursting bubbles, coconut flakes, gummy bears
¡Arriba Coffee!
Coffee lovers, this one’s for you! Set down your iced coffee and pick up a spoon to enjoy our ¡Arriba Coffee! flavor. Made with 100% Arabica coffee beans, this signature java flavor is a true delight for coffee enthusiasts.
16 Handles Recommended Toppings: Chocolate chips, Ghirardelli™ caramel sauce, whipped cream, cinnamon streusel
Peanut Butter Perfection
Calling all peanut butter fans! Peanut Butter Perfection is a gluten-free soft serve made exclusively for 16 Handles. It brings together the best of both peanut butter and dessert with real peanuts. Don’t be shy with the toppings; this flavor pairs perfectly with a variety of options!
16 Handles Recommended Toppings: Peanut butter cups, chopped HEATH bar, chopped Kit Kat, Reese’s Pieces, Nutella, peanut butter sauce
Made with Nutella®
It’s hard not to love Nutella, and that’s why our Made with Nutella flavor is a favorite. Swirled into our Artisan Sweet Cream fro-yo base, this flavor combines the rich taste of Nutella with the creaminess of frozen yogurt. It’s a simple yet life-changing experience!
16 Handles Recommended Toppings: Nutella (available in a squeezable bottle!), hot fudge, hazelnut crunch, crushed peanuts, Ghirardelli™ chocolate sauce
Mint Chocolate Chip
Fresh minty soft serve with chocolate pieces swirled in? Yes, please! Mint Chocolate Chip is a classic ice cream flavor that gets its fro-yo spin at 16 Handles.
16 Handles Recommended Toppings: Hot fudge, chocolate chips, dark polar bits, Ghirardelli™ chocolate sauce, chocolate cookie crunch
Chocolate Hazelnut Truffle, made with cashew milk
If you’re looking for a rich, creamy chocolate flavor without dairy, look no further than our Chocolate Hazelnut Truffle. Made with cashew milk, this vegan and gluten-free Artisan soft serve checks all the boxes.
16 Handles Recommended Toppings: Crushed peanuts, carob chips, fresh strawberries
Graham Cracker
Think outside the box with our Graham Cracker fro-yo. This flavor has been a fan favorite since its launch, combining the signature cracker taste with the smoothness of frozen yogurt. Add some graham cracker crumbs and chocolate chips for that extra crunch!
16 Handles Recommended Toppings: Graham cracker crumbs, hot fudge, chocolate chips, marshmallow sauce
Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream
Developed with one of New York’s top pastry chefs, our Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream flavor is a signature creation. Real strawberries and shortcake cookies are mixed into our creamy ice cream base, resulting in a perfectly pink and ultra-rich soft serve that captures the essence of the beloved dessert.
16 Handles Recommended Toppings: Raspberry sauce, yogurt chips, cheesecake bites, graham cracker crumbs, fresh strawberries
Peanut Butter Cup
Building upon the fan-favorite Peanut Butter Perfection, we took it a step further and added chocolate. Peanut Butter Cup combines peanut butter fro-yo with milk chocolate and cocoa butter, creating an indulgence like no other.
16 Handles Recommended Toppings: Peanut butter cups, chocolate cookie crunch, crushed Snickers, Reese’s Pieces, peanut butter sauce, Ghirardelli™ chocolate sauce
Yo Soy Vanilla
Yo Soy Vanilla is a vegan, soy-milk soft serve flavored with real Tahitian vanilla. Crafted by our chefs in 2013, this dairy-free alternative has become one of our most popular flavors. Pair it with Chocolate Hazelnut Truffle for a classic sundae without the dairy!
16 Handles Recommended Toppings: Fresh fruit, carob chips, Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough by DŌ NYC
Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors or looking to explore something new, 16 Handles has something for everyone. Visit our Ice Cream directory to find a location near you and indulge in the best Handel’s Ice Cream flavors available!
